UPSC Previous Year Question | Mains GS2 | 2024

Discuss India as a secular state and compare with the secular principles of the US constitution. (Answer in 250 words)

Answer

Introduction

Introduction

Secularism protects freedom of conscience and equal citizenship, but India and the United States institutionalise the principle through different constitutional histories.

India

India’s model

  • The Preamble, Articles 14, 15, 16, 25–28 and 29–30 establish equality, religious freedom, minority rights and limits on religious discrimination.
  • Indian secularism is principled distance: the State may regulate secular aspects, reform oppressive practices and support equal religious freedoms.
  • It does not demand hostility to religion; it requires constitutional morality and substantive equality.

United States And Comparison

US model and comparison

  • The First Amendment combines a non-establishment clause with free exercise; the State cannot establish religion, while religious practice receives protection subject to law.
  • The US tradition emphasises institutional separation, whereas India permits calibrated engagement for reform and social justice.
  • Both reject theocracy, but Indian affirmative accommodation reflects pluralism and historical disadvantage more explicitly.

Keywords

Keywords: secularism, freedom of conscience, Articles 14–16 and 25–30, First Amendment, principled distance, equal citizenship.

Topics: indian constitution, india-us comparison, polity and governance, secularism