UPSC Previous Year Question | Mains GS2 | 2024

Examine the need for electoral reforms as suggested by various committees with particular reference to "one nation – one election" principle. (Answer in 150 words)

Answer

Introduction

Introduction

Electoral reform seeks to deepen representation, improve integrity and make elections more efficient while preserving constitutional accountability.

Need And Committee Recommendations

Need and recommendations

  • The Law Commission, Election Commission and Parliamentary committees have highlighted criminalisation, money power, paid news, opaque political finance and inner-party democracy.
  • Simultaneous elections may reduce repeated Model Code restrictions, administrative diversion and campaign expenditure, while enabling longer policy horizons.
  • It can also improve voter convenience and reduce governance interruptions.

Concerns And Way Forward

Concerns and way forward

  • Fixed-term legislatures, premature dissolution, federal autonomy and accountability to voters require careful constitutional design.
  • Consensus among States, constructive vote of no-confidence, synchronised terms and adequate EVM/security logistics are essential.
  • Reforms should also include transparent funding, speedy trials, stronger ECI independence and proportional penalties for violations.

Keywords

Keywords: Law Commission, ECI, Model Code, federalism, accountability, constitutional amendment.

Topics: election management, electoral reforms, one nation one election, polity and governance