UPSC Previous Year Question | Mains GS1 | 2022

Given the diversities among tribal communities in India in which specific context should they be considered as a single category? (Answer in 150 words)

Answer

Introduction

Indian tribes differ in language, ecology, economy, social organisation and historical experience. Treating them as one homogeneous culture is inaccurate, but a common category is useful for rights and policy.

Contexts

Context for a common category

  • Constitutional protection: Scheduled Tribe identification enables safeguards under Articles 15(4), 16(4), 46, 244 and the Fifth and Sixth Schedules.
  • Historical marginalisation: displacement, land alienation, exploitation by intermediaries and low access to health and education create shared justice concerns.
  • Collective rights: Forest Rights Act recognition, Gram Sabha participation under PESA and protection of customary resources require an administrative category.
  • Political representation: reserved seats and institutional voice address under-representation.

Nuance

Need for differentiated policy

Uniform schemes can erase Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups, nomadic groups, remote communities and distinct customary institutions. The category should therefore be a legal and welfare instrument, not a claim of cultural sameness; decentralised, community-specific planning is essential.

Keywords

Scheduled Tribes; Fifth Schedule; Sixth Schedule; PESA; Forest Rights Act; diversity; substantive equality.

Topics: constitutional safeguards, diversity and identity, indian society, tribal communities