UPSC Previous Year Question | Mains GS2 | 2020
What introduces friction into the ties between India and the United States is that Washington is still unable to find for India a position in its global strategy, which would satisfy India’s national self-esteem and ambitions’. Explain with suitable examples. (Answer in 250 words)
Answer
Introduction
India and the United States are partners in technology, defence and the Indo-Pacific, but their relationship is shaped by different priorities and expectations.
Analysis
Sources of friction
- India seeks strategic autonomy and multi-alignment, while Washington often expects clearer alignment with its China-centred Indo-Pacific strategy.
- India’s defence relationship with Russia, including legacy systems, conflicts with US sanctions policy and interoperability expectations.
- Energy security and connectivity with Iran create difficulties for US sanctions regimes.
- Trade disputes over tariffs, market access, data, intellectual property and localisation reflect India’s development priorities against US commercial demands.
- US immigration and H-1B restrictions affect India’s services sector and skilled workforce.
- India wants recognition as a leading power, permanent UN Security Council reform and technology access, not merely a balancing partner.
Convergence
Defence exercises, foundational agreements, counter-terrorism, critical technology, diaspora ties and cooperation in the Quad provide a substantial base.
Way forward
Respect strategic autonomy, deepen economic reciprocity, establish resilient technology supply chains and manage disagreements through institutional dialogue.
Conclusion
The partnership will mature when the US treats India as an autonomous pole rather than a subordinate ally.
Managing friction requires realistic expectations on both sides. India should communicate its red lines while expanding areas of mutual gain; the United States should accommodate differentiated partnerships and support India’s rise through technology, investment and institutional reform.
Keywords
India-US relations; strategic autonomy; Indo-Pacific; technology partnership
Topics: global strategy, india-us relations, international relations, strategic autonomy